Is Freemasonry Like the Mafia? (Exploring Similarities & Comparisons)

Freemasonry, an ancient and honorable fraternity, has often been subject to myths, misconceptions, and sensationalized portrayals.

One such misconception that has persisted over the years is the notion that Freemasonry operates like a clandestine organization akin to a mafia.

In this article, we aim to dispel this myth and shed light on the true nature of Freemasonry’s organizational structure.

We will explore the principles, values, and governance that underpin Freemasonry, highlighting its commitment to morality, brotherhood, and personal growth.

By examining the transparent and democratic nature of Freemasonry, we will debunk the notion of a secretive hierarchy or hidden agenda.

TLDR: No, Freemasonry is not like the Mafia. Freemasonry is a fraternal organization with a rich history focused on moral development, brotherhood, and personal growth. It operates transparently and follows a democratic structure, promoting integrity and ethical conduct among its members. The notion of Freemasonry being similar to the Mafia is a misconception and not based on reality.

Is Freemasonry Like the Mafia

The Freemasons’ Community: A first-of-its-kind online community for those looking to learn more about the mysteries of Freemasonry in the company of like-minded men. Click here to learn more.

The History of Freemasonry


Freemasonry is a fraternal organization that traces its origins back to the medieval guilds of stonemasons.

These guilds were responsible for the construction of many of the cathedrals and other buildings that still stand in Europe today.

Over time, the guilds began to admit members who were not stonemasons, and the organization evolved into what we know today as Freemasonry.

Freemasonry in England

Freemasonry, as we know it today, began to take shape in England in the 17th century.

The first Grand Lodge was formed in London in 1717, and from there, the organization spread rapidly throughout England and eventually to other parts of the world.

The Grand Lodge of England is still one of the most influential Masonic organizations in the world today.

Freemasonry in America

Freemasonry played a significant role in the early history of the United States as well.

Many of the Founding Fathers, including George Washington and Benjamin Franklin, were Freemasons.

In fact, 13 of the 39 signatures on the U.S. Constitution belonged to Masons. Freemasonry also played a role in the development of American politics in the early 19th century, with many Masons holding political office at the state and national levels.

Throughout its history, Freemasonry has been associated with secrecy and mystery.

The organization has been accused of everything from devil worship to being a front for the Illuminati.

However, most Masons insist that the organization is simply a fraternity that promotes moral and ethical values and provides a sense of community and brotherhood for its members.

The Freemasonry-Mafia Comparison

Origins of the Comparison

The comparison between Freemasonry and the Mafia is not a new one.

The origins of the comparison can be traced back to the early 19th century when Freemasonry was at its peak in popularity.

At the time, Freemasonry was seen as a shadow government that was attempting to control the world through its secret rituals and codes.

This perception was fueled by the disappearance and presumed murder of William Morgan, a former Mason who had threatened to expose the secrets of the organization.

The incident led to a wave of anti-Masonic sentiment in the United States and contributed to the formation of the Anti-Masonic Party.

Structure Comparison

The structure of Freemasonry and the Mafia is often compared due to their similar hierarchical structures.

Both organizations have a pyramid-like structure with a leader at the top, followed by a small group of trusted advisors and lieutenants, and then a large number of foot soldiers at the bottom.

This structure allows for a high degree of control and coordination, making it easier to carry out illegal activities such as murder and corruption.

Evidence for the Comparison

Despite these similarities, it is important to note that the comparison between Freemasonry and the Mafia is not entirely accurate.

While there sadly have been instances of corruption and criminal activity within the Masonic organization (especially in Italy/Sicily, the birthplace of the mafia) the vast majority of Masons are law-abiding citizens who are dedicated to their community and the betterment of society.

Controversies Surrounding Freemasonry

freemasonry and the vatican
The Catholic Church has had a long and contentious relationship with Freemasonry.
NB: Aspiring Masons and Master Masons from all over the world look forward to our emails. If you’d like to join them, sign up for Masonic Find’s newsletter. It’s free and our next email goes out in a few hours.

Freemasonry has been the subject of numerous controversies throughout its history.

Some of these controversies have arisen due to conspiracy theories, while others have been the result of political or religious opposition.

Conspiracy Theories

One of the most persistent controversies surrounding Freemasonry is the belief that it is involved in a vast conspiracy to control world events.

This theory is often linked to the Illuminati, a secret society that was founded in Bavaria in the late 18th century and was believed to have infiltrated Freemasonry.

Of the claims that Freemasonry exerts control over politics, perhaps the best-known example is the New World Order theory.

This theory posits that a secretive elite group of Freemasons is working to establish a totalitarian world government that will control all aspects of human life.

This, of course, is false.

Anti-Masonic Party

In the United States, the Anti-Masonic Party was formed in the early 19th century in opposition to the influence of Freemasonry in politics.

The party was especially strong in the Northeastern states and was a precursor to the modern-day Whig Party.

The Anti-Masonic Party was founded in 1828 after the disappearance of William Morgan, a former Mason who had threatened to reveal the secrets of the organization.

Morgan’s disappearance was widely believed to have been the work of Masons, and the incident led to a wave of anti-Masonic sentiment.

Forbidden by the Catholic Church

The Catholic Church has had a long and contentious relationship with Freemasonry.

In 1738, Pope Clement XII issued a papal bull that declared membership in Freemasonry to be a grave sin and prohibited Catholics from joining the organization.

The prohibition was later reaffirmed by several other popes, including Pope Leo XIII, who issued an encyclical in 1884 that condemned Freemasonry as a “sect of the devil.”

The Vatican’s opposition to Freemasonry was based on the belief that the organization promoted a secular worldview that was incompatible with Catholicism.

In conclusion…

While there are some faint similarities between the organizational structures of Freemasonry and the Mafia, it is important to note that these similarities do not necessarily imply that Freemasonry is a criminal organization.

The secretive nature of Freemasonry, while often criticized, is not inherently nefarious.

In fact, secrecy is a common aspect of many faiths and philosophical schools of thought.

Additionally, the fraternal and philanthropic aspects of Freemasonry are well-documented and widely recognized.

It is also important to note that while there have been instances of corruption and criminal activity within Freemasonry, these instances are not representative of the organization as a whole.

Just as there are corrupt individuals within any group or organization, there may be individuals within Freemasonry who abuse their power or engage in illegal activities.